If I’m being honest, I was a picky kid who always ordered chicken fingers at restaurants. Now that I’m an adult, I’m just as picky about my chicken fingers—the chicken has to be moist and juicy, the flavor has to be perfect, and I’m probably in a hurry, so don’t make me cook them for more than a few minutes.
Along with Grilled Chicken Breast and Grilled Chicken Thighs, I unlocked the trick to grilling chicken tenders that boast golden, grill-marked outsides and moist, juicy insides.
They’re also well-seasoned. The flavor, while mild and kid-friendly, still permeates all the way to their centers. No bland chicken for us!.
You’ll find helpful tips and suggestions for how to serve these easy grilled chicken tenders too.
You can eat them on their own for a quick and healthy meal, but I’ve been really enjoying using them in place of basic shredded chicken in meal prep recipes like salads and wraps. For example, you can find this stovetop method for How to Cook Shredded Chicken, this Crock Pot Shredded Chicken, or this Instant Pot Chicken.
And if it rains today or you don’t have a grill, I can also tell you how to cook the chicken tenders in other ways.
Are you staring at those chicken tenderloins in your fridge and wondering how to transform them into something delicious without much hassle? Your George Foreman grill might just be the kitchen hero you need! I’ve been using mine for years, and let me tell you – once you master the timing, you’ll never look back.
How Long to Grill Chicken Tenderloins on a George Foreman?
The short answer is that chicken tenderloins cook in 4 to 8 minutes on a George Foreman grill.
But honestly, that’s just scratching the surface. The perfect timing depends on several factors that I’ll break down for ya. After all, nobody wants dry, overcooked chicken or (even worse) undercooked poultry!
Factors That Affect Cooking Time
Before you put those tenders on the grill, think about these things that could change how long they take to cook.
- Thickness of tenderloins – Thicker pieces naturally need more time
- Starting temperature – Cold chicken straight from the fridge takes longer than room temp
- Grill model – Different George Foreman models heat differently
- Preheating – A properly preheated grill cooks more efficiently
- Marinade used – Some marinades can affect cooking time
Step-by-Step Guide to Perfect George Foreman Chicken Tenderloins
1. Prep Work (30+ minutes before cooking)
First things first, lemme walk you through the prep work:
Pat chicken tenderloins dry with paper towels Season or marinate (at least 30 minutes, overnight is better!) If using frozen tenderloins, thaw completely in refrigerator firstPro Tip I like to marinate mine overnight with a mixture of olive oil, minced garlic, lemon juice, and Italian seasoning The acid in the lemon helps tenderize the meat while adding amazing flavor!
2. Preheat Your Grill (5 minutes)
This step is SUPER important and many people skip it! Don’t be that person.
Plug in your George Foreman grill Close the lid Allow to heat for approximately 5 minutesA properly preheated grill sears the outside of the chicken quickly, locking in those precious juices.
3. Grilling Time (4-8 minutes)
Now for the main event
Lightly spray the grill plates with cooking spray (optional but helpful) Place chicken tenderloins on the grill in a single layer Leave space between pieces (don't overcrowd!) Close the lid and cook for 4-6 minutes for thinner tenderloins Cook for 6-8 minutes for thicker piecesIMPORTANT: A meat thermometer is the best way to be sure the meat is done. For safety reasons, chicken should be cooked all the way through to 165°F (74°C).
4. Rest Before Serving (5 minutes)
Don’t skip this step! Even though it’s tempting to dig right in:
Remove chicken from grill Let rest for about 5 minutes This allows juices to redistribute throughout the meatCommon Mistakes to Avoid
I’ve made pretty much all these mistakes at some point, so learn from my experiences:
- Skipping the preheat – Your chicken won’t sear properly and might stick
- Overcrowding the grill – This causes uneven cooking and steaming instead of grilling
- Not using a thermometer – Visual cues aren’t reliable enough for food safety
- Cutting into the chicken immediately – You’ll lose all those flavorful juices!
- Forgetting to clean the grill after use – Nobody wants yesterday’s chicken flavor in today’s meal
Flavor Variations to Try
Here are some of my favorite ways to spice up chicken tenderloins:
| Flavor Profile | Key Ingredients |
|---|---|
| Classic Garlic Herb | Olive oil, minced garlic, Italian herbs, lemon |
| Spicy Southwest | Hot sauce, lime juice, cumin, chili powder |
| Asian Inspired | Soy sauce, honey, ginger, sesame oil |
| BBQ Style | Your favorite BBQ sauce, brown sugar, garlic powder |
| Buttermilk Tenderizer | Buttermilk, salt, pepper, paprika (soak overnight) |
Serving Suggestions
These versatile tenderloins can be used in so many ways! Here’s what I usually do with mine:
- Slice and add to salads for extra protein
- Serve with veggies and rice for a complete meal
- Make quick wraps with lettuce, tomato and a sauce
- Chop and add to pasta dishes
- Use in quesadillas with cheese and veggies
- Meal prep for the week ahead (they freeze well after cooking!)
Troubleshooting Common Issues
My chicken turns out dry. What am I doing wrong?
Remember that chicken tenderloins are lean and cook quickly, so don’t cook it too long. With a thermometer, take them out as soon as they reach 165°F.
The chicken sticks to my grill plates. Help!
Make sure your grill is properly preheated and consider using a light coating of high-temperature cooking spray before adding the chicken.
My chicken looks done on the outside but is undercooked inside.
This usually happens with thicker pieces or when the grill is too hot. Try reducing the heat (if your model allows) or slightly increasing the cooking time.
Real-Life Time-Saving Tips
As a busy person who still wants delicious meals, here are some shortcuts I’ve discovered:
- Batch cooking – Grill a whole package of tenderloins at once and refrigerate for quick meals throughout the week
- Pre-marinate and freeze – Prepare several bags of marinated raw tenderloins and freeze them. Thaw overnight before cooking
- Double duty – While your chicken cooks, prepare your sides or set the table to maximize efficiency
FAQs About George Foreman Chicken Tenderloins
Can I use frozen chicken tenderloins directly on the George Foreman grill?
It’s not recommended. Frozen chicken will cook unevenly, increasing the risk of undercooked portions. Always thaw completely in the refrigerator first.
Should I spray my George Foreman grill before cooking chicken?
A light coating of cooking spray can help prevent sticking, especially if your chicken isn’t marinated. Use an oil with a high smoke point.
How do I clean my George Foreman grill after cooking chicken?
Unplug and allow to cool slightly (still warm makes cleaning easier). Use the cleaning tool that came with your grill or a damp paper towel to wipe away residue. For removable plates, follow manufacturer’s instructions for dishwasher safety.
Can I add cheese to my chicken while it’s grilling?
Yes! Add cheese during the last minute of cooking for a melty topping.
Final Thoughts
Mastering the art of grilling chicken tenderloins on your George Foreman is all about finding that sweet spot in timing – typically 4-8 minutes depending on thickness. Once you’ve nailed it, you’ll have a quick, healthy protein option at your fingertips any day of the week.
The beauty of this cooking method is its simplicity. With minimal equipment and prep time, you can create juicy, flavorful chicken that works in countless recipes. My family requests these tenderloins at least twice a week, and I’m always happy to oblige because they’re so easy to make!
What’s your favorite way to season chicken tenderloins? Drop a comment below – I’m always looking for new flavor ideas to try on my trusty George Foreman!
What to Serve with Grilled Chicken Tenders
As I mentioned, I love making a big batch of these for meal prep. Here are some ways to use them throughout the week.
- For extra protein, add them to pasta dishes like Pasta al Limone. They would taste great with this Adult Mac and Cheese for both kids and adults.
- You can add chicken tenders to your salads all week to make them filling.
- Diced chicken tenders are a great way to step up your pizza game. This Broccoli Pizza Crust is a great choice.
- For a quick and healthy lunch, put some chicken tenders inside a wrap. You could also try this Grilled Chicken Sandwich.
The possibilities are endless!
How to Cook Grilled Chicken Tenders
Use this recipe as a springboard and feel free to play around by adding different seasonings.
Italian seasoning is a favorite of ours. For a Mexican twist, try chili powder or cumin.
- Chicken Tenders. Juicy, fast-cooking, and great for healthy meals. Other types of meat have more calories than chicken, but chicken is low in calories and high in lean protein. Chicken breast that has been cut into 1 to 1 1/2-inch strips can be used instead of tenders if you don’t have any.
- Salt Water Marinade (a. k. a. Brine). If you remember the important salty marinade I talked about above, it’s made of soy sauce, water, honey, and a little seasoning (salt and pepper are enough to start).
- Vinegar. Another way to make meat tender is to add acid to it. This will start to break down the meat’s fibers. I used apple cider vinegar, which has a hint of fruit, for this simple marinade. You can also use lime juice, lemon juice, or another kind of vinegar. Each imparts a different (but delicious) flavor.