For generations we New Englanders just assumed that our neighbors shared our preference for brown eggs. All the while the heretical white egg was making in roads along our southern border.
Do you remember the slogan “Brown eggs are local eggs … and local eggs are fresh?”
Hey, egg lovers! Have you ever looked at a carton of brown eggs in the grocery store and wondered if they were better than the white ones? I know I have. My friend and I used to argue about this all the time—don’t you think? The color of the shell has nothing to do with what’s inside; it all depends on the chicken that laid the egg. Find out the truth about brown eggs and whether they’re worth the extra money or if it’s all just a pretty shell game.
We’re gonna dive deep into what makes brown eggs brown, bust some myths about health and taste, figure out why they’re often pricier, and help ya decide which eggs to grab next time you’re shoppin’. Stick with me, ‘cause I’ve got the scoop to make your egg-buyin’ life a whole lot easier.
What Makes an Egg Brown? It’s All About the Bird!
First things first: the breed of chicken that laid the egg determines its color, whether it’s brown, white, or even blue-green. Isn’t that crazy? I used to think it had something to do with the feed or some fancy farm trick, but it’s mostly genetics.
- Chicken Breeds and Egg Color: Hens like Rhode Island Reds, New Hampshire, or Plymouth Rocks usually lay brown eggs. On the flip side, breeds like Leghorns or White Rocks pop out white ones. And if you’re lucky at a farmer’s market, you might spot blue or green eggs from Araucana hens. How cool is that?
- How It Happens: All eggs start white inside the hen. As the egg moves through her system, a pigment gets added to the shell right before it’s laid. For brown eggs, that pigment makes the outside brown, but if ya crack one open, the inside of the shell is still white. It’s like nature’s paint job.
- Fun Fact: Wanna guess an egg’s color before it’s laid? Check the hen’s earlobes. Yup, earlobes! Hens with red earlobes often lay brown eggs, while white earlobes mean white eggs. Bet ya didn’t see that comin’!
So, when I pick up a carton of brown eggs, I’m basically choosin’ eggs from a specific type of chicken. It’s not about quality or anything inside—just the bird’s DNA doin’ its thing. But does that brown shell mean it’s healthier? Let’s get into that next.
Are Brown Eggs Healthier Than White? Busting the Myth
I’ll admit, I used to think brown eggs were somehow better for ya. They look more “natural,” right? Like they came straight from a rustic farm instead of a factory. But lemme tell ya, that’s a straight-up myth. The color of the shell don’t change what’s inside the egg.
- Nutrition’s the Same: Whether it’s brown or white, an egg’s got the same goodies—about 6 grams of high-quality protein, vitamins like B12, and minerals like selenium, all for around 70 calories. It’s a powerhouse no matter the shell.
- No Difference Unless Enhanced: The only time nutrition changes is if the eggs are jazzed up with extras, like omega-3s. Some farmers feed hens special stuff like flaxseed to boost omega-3 fats in the yolk. But that ain’t tied to color—brown or white eggs can both be enhanced.
- What Really Matters: If ya want a healthier egg, it’s not about brown versus white. Look at how the hen was raised. Hens roamin’ in sunshine make eggs with more vitamin D—sometimes 3 to 4 times more than indoor hens. And a diet with grass or special feed can up the omega-3s or vitamin E. Shell color? Irrelevant.
So, next time someone tells ya brown eggs are the “healthy choice,” you can set ‘em straight. I learned this the hard way after spendin’ extra on brown eggs for years, thinkin’ I was doin’ my body a favor. Turns out, I was just buyin’ a prettier shell!
Do Brown Eggs Taste Better? Let’s Crack That Open
Alright, let’s talk flavor. Some folks swear by brown eggs, sayin’ they’ve got a richer, “eggier” taste I’ve even heard peeps claim white eggs taste bland in comparison. But is there any truth to this, or is it all in our heads?
- Color Don’t Affect Taste: Here’s the deal—brown eggs and white eggs taste the same. Blindfold yourself and try ‘em side by side; ya won’t be able to tell the difference. Even the fanciest food critic couldn’t guess the color by flavor alone.
- What Does Change Taste: Now, other stuff can mess with how an egg tastes. Freshness is huge—eggs straight from a local farm often taste better ‘cause they ain’t been sittin’ around. The hen’s diet matters too; if she’s eatin’ varied stuff like grass or bugs, the yolk might be deeper orange and have a bolder flavor. Cookin’ method plays a role as well—boiled versus scrambled can taste different dependin’ on the feed.
- My Take: I’ve cooked with both, and I ain’t noticed a lick of difference. Last week, I made a scramble with brown eggs, and it tasted just like the white egg scramble I did a month ago. It’s all about how fresh they are and how ya cook ‘em.
So, if you’re pickin’ brown eggs for taste, ya might be wastin’ your time. Save that energy for findin’ the freshest carton or a killer recipe. Speakin’ of wastin’ time, why the heck are brown eggs often more expensive? Let’s dig into that.
Why Are Brown Eggs Such Pricey Lil’ Buggers?
You are not crazy if you have ever seen that brown eggs cost a little more than white ones at the store. It used to bother me—why pay more for something that’s pretty much the same? There are a few reasons for this sneaky price hike.
- Bigger Hens, Bigger Costs: The chickens that lay brown eggs, like Rhode Island Reds, tend to be a tad larger than white-egg layers like Leghorns. Bigger birds eat more feed, which means more money for the farmer. That cost gets passed on to us.
- Slightly Fancier Feed: Sometimes, the feed for brown-egg hens has a few extra nutrients to help with that shell color. It ain’t a huge difference, but it adds up, makin’ their upkeep a bit pricier.
- Market Perception: Here’s the sneaky part—brown eggs are often tied to “specialty” labels like free-range or organic. Even though color don’t mean better, stores know folks think brown eggs look healthier or more natural, so they jack up the price. It’s marketin’, pure and simple.
- Past vs. Present: Back in the day, brown-egg hens laid fewer eggs, so the price was higher to make up for less product. That ain’t always true now, but the higher price tag kinda stuck around like a bad habit.
I remember grabbin’ a carton of brown eggs once ‘cause they were on sale, thinkin’ I got a steal. Turns out, the regular price was way more than white eggs. Now I check twice before tossin’ ‘em in my cart. But price ain’t the only thing to think about when buyin’ eggs. Let’s chat about what really matters.
Beyond Color: What Should Ya Look for in Eggs?
Now that we know the difference between brown and white doesn’t mean much, what should we look for in a carton? Trust me, there’s more to it than just shell color. Here’s the stuff I keep an eye on now.
Egg Labels and What They Mean
Egg cartons come with all sorts of fancy words—organic, cage-free, free-range. But what do they actually tell ya? Here’s a quick rundown:
- Organic: These eggs come from hens fed organic, non-GMO grub and have access to the outdoors year-round. No hormones or unnecessary antibiotics either. They ain’t proven to be more nutritious, but the hens probably live better, and sunlight might boost vitamin D in the eggs.
- Cage-Free: Sounds nice, but it just means the hens ain’t in tiny cages. They’re still indoors, often packed tight, with no outdoor access. Might be a smidge better for the bird, but don’t expect healthier eggs.
- Free-Range: This means hens get some outdoor time, which is better for their quality of life. Sunlight exposure can up the vitamin D in eggs, so there’s a potential health perk here.
- Omega-3 Enriched: These eggs come from hens fed a diet with omega-3 fats, like flaxseed. The result? Eggs with more of that heart-healthy fat. Studies show eatin’ these daily might lower blood pressure or triglycerides. Color don’t matter—look for the label.
- Backyard or Local: Eggs from a neighbor’s coop or small farm are often fresher and from hens livin’ in natural settings. They might have more omega-3s or vitamin E if the hens eat grass, but ya gotta trust the source for hygiene.
I’ve started buyin’ free-range when I can afford it, not ‘cause of color, but ‘cause I like knowin’ the hens got some fresh air. Plus, the yolks seem yellower, which just feels right in my omelets.
A Quick Comparison: Brown vs. White Eggs
Still on the fence? Here’s a handy table to break down the main points between brown and white eggs. Keep this in mind next time you’re starin’ at cartons.
| Aspect | Brown Eggs | White Eggs |
|---|---|---|
| Shell Color Source | Pigment from hen breed (e.g., Rhode Island Red) | No pigment, from breeds like Leghorn |
| Nutrition | Same as white unless enriched | Same as brown unless enriched |
| Taste | No difference based on color | No difference based on color |
| Cost | Often higher due to hen size/feed costs | Usually cheaper |
| Common Perception | Seen as “healthier” or “natural” | Seen as standard or less fancy |
See? Not much difference when ya strip it down. I use this kinda mental checklist now instead of just grabbin’ whatever looks prettiest.
Cookin’ with Brown Eggs: Does It Matter?
Now, let’s get to the fun part—usin’ these eggs in the kitchen. Whether ya got brown or white eggs, they cook up the same. I’ve baked cakes, whipped up scrambles, and boiled dozens of eggs over the years, and the shell color never changed the game.
- No Difference in Recipes: Need eggs for a fluffy soufflé or a dense brownie? Brown eggs work just as good as white. The texture, bindin’, or rise ain’t affected by the shell.
- Aesthetic Vibes: Only time color matters is if you’re decoratin’—like for Easter. Brown eggs take dye different than white ones, givin’ ya unique shades. I’ve had a blast experimentin’ with natural dyes on brown eggs; they turn out with deeper, earthier tones.
- Freshness Tip: No matter the color, check freshness by droppin’ an egg in water. Sinks? Fresh. Floats? Toss it. I’ve saved myself from a bad batch of brown eggs with this trick more than once.
So, grab whatever carton ya got and get cookin’. I’m plannin’ to make a big ol’ frittata this weekend with brown eggs, just ‘cause I like how they look in the carton. But the taste? Gonna be just as yummy as with white ones.
Why Do We Even Care About Egg Color?
Ya might be wonderin’ why we’re so hung up on brown versus white in the first place. I think it’s ‘cause food ain’t just fuel—it’s culture, it’s vibes, it’s personal. Brown eggs feel more “farm-to-table” to a lotta folks, even if that ain’t always true. And hey, in a world where we got a million choices at the store, pickin’ a carton can feel like a lil’ statement about who we are.
I remember my grandma always buyin’ white eggs ‘cause they were cheaper, and she’d scoff at brown ones as a “fancy waste of money.” But my hipster cousin? Swears by brown eggs for his avocado toast pics on social media. It’s funny how somethin’ so small can say so much about us.
Other Factors That Sneak Into Your Egg Choice
Beyond color and labels, there’s a few other things that might sway ya when buyin’ eggs. I’ve learned to peek at these over time, and they’ve changed how I shop.
- Size Matters: Eggs come in medium, large, extra-large, and jumbo. Most recipes call for large, so I stick with that unless I’m feelin’ wild. Brown or white, the size impacts how much egg ya get, not the color.
- Freshness Dates: Always check the date on the carton. Fresher eggs last longer and taste better, no matter the shell. I’ve accidentally bought old brown eggs before, and let me tell ya, they weren’t worth the price.
- Local vs. Commercial: If ya got a farmers’ market nearby, give it a shot. Local eggs—often brown just ‘cause of the breeds small farmers keep—can be fresher and from happier hens. I’ve noticed a difference in yolk color and taste with local ones, and it ain’t about the shell.
- Storage Tips: Once ya buy ‘em, store eggs in the fridge, not the door, to keep ‘em stable. I used to leave mine on the counter like in old movies, but they spoil quicker that way. Learned that lesson after a stinky mishap with a brown egg batch.
These lil’ details add up. I’ve gotten better at pickin’ eggs by focusin’ on what’s practical, not just what’s pretty. Brown eggs might catch my eye, but I’m checkin’ labels and dates first now.
Let’s Wrap This Egg-venture Up!
So, where do we land on brown eggs? They’re cool, they’re pretty, but they ain’t some magical superfood compared to white eggs. The color’s just a quirk of the chicken breed, not a sign of better nutrition or taste. Brown eggs might cost ya more ‘cause of bigger hens and marketin’ tricks, but at the end of the day, it’s about how the hen was raised and what she ate that really counts.
Next time you’re at the store, don’t sweat the shell color. Look for stuff like free-range or omega-3 enriched if ya wanna level up your egg game. Me? I’m still partial to brown eggs for no good reason other than I like how they look in my fridge. But I ain’t foolin’ myself into thinkin’ they’re superior.
What about you? Are ya team brown egg or team white egg? Got any egg-citin’ recipes or stories to share? Drop ‘em in the comments below—I’d love to hear how ya pick your cartons or whip up your breakfast. And hey, if ya found this helpful, share it with a pal who’s as egg-obsessed as we are. Let’s keep this convo crackin’!
Signup First Name* Last Name* Email Address* Password* Confirm Password* Captcha is required
For generations we New Englanders just assumed that our neighbors shared our preference for brown eggs. All the while the heretical white egg was making in roads along our southern border.
By L.F. Willard|Aug 01 2022| 
Do you remember the slogan “Brown eggs are local eggs … and local eggs are fresh?”
Brown Eggs vs. White Eggs“War of the Eggs”
New England has been at war, but most people who are involved don’t notice it every time they crack an egg into a frying pan. It may not seem important whether an egg has a brown or white shell, but it’s important to remember that the Lilliputians got into a shooting war over whether the morning egg should be opened at the big end or the small end of the shell. Already we are a country divided by brown eggs vs. white eggs here in New England — while the rest of us insist by a margin of 9 to 1 that brown eggs are aesthetically, morally, and gastronomically superior, Connecticut residents are evenly divided in their preference, splitting geographically at the Connecticut River. The people who eat brown eggs and live east of the river will be thought of as from New England in terms of eggs, while the people who eat white eggs and live west of the river will have to be thought of as from New York and, really, the rest of the United States in terms of eggs. white eggs controversy. Since I moved from Vermont to west of the Connecticut River, even if it’s only by a few miles, I’m kind of stuck because I live in enemy territory. My taste in eggs was irrevocably determined by my boyhood experiences. The farmer brought us eggs twice a week, so we didn’t have to buy them at the store. These eggs were brown and they were fresh. White eggs were sometimes available at the grocery store, usually in time for Easter. They were called cold storage eggs, not really edible, but they were thought to be indispensable for Easter egg coloring. As I remember, the eggs were hard-boiled (it seemed the safe thing to do, my parents thought) and were dipped into a dye solution that reeked of vinegar. There it was: the link. To this day, I can’t walk by a supermarket white-egg display without smelling vinegar. This is my cue to look for some brown eggs, and in this border territory they can be found, although they cost perhaps three cents a dozen more. Even though I didn’t know it at the time, one of the oldest parts of my Yankee heritage was my love of brown eggs. Chinese chickens that laid brown eggs were brought to New England on Yankee clipper ships that had stopped in China and Indonesia. The Chinese were the first people to make eggs. These birds were recognized for their vigor and stamina and soon became invaluable to the colonists. In the early 1800s, Little Compton, Rhode Island, had a thriving poultry industry. This is where the famous Rhode Island Red, one of the first domestic brown-egg breeds, came from. This breed was further developed into the New Hampshire Red. Today one of the most favored brown-egg layers is the Silver Cross, the result of mating a Rhode Island Red rooster with a Barred Plymouth Rock hen. E. B. In one of his essays, White writes about this bird: “Her egg is so richly brown and so wondrously beautiful that it defies description.” So, if brown eggs are so important to New England’s history and are so sought after, why should the brown-egg industry be afraid of white eggs? Don’t we have the guts to stand up for what we believe in? Are brown eggs losing ground? white eggs answer lies in the realm of economics. Brown-egg layers are bigger, sturdier birds. They eat more, and transportation costs make feed more expensive in the East. Add to the cheaper grain costs in the West and South the White Leghorn hen, described by E. B. White as the greatest egg-machine on two legs, and the only conclusion one can arrive at is that supermarkets can bring white eggs into New England and undersell brown eggs by anywhere from three to ten cents a dozen. New England brown-egg producers are doing what they can to lower production costs. In the meantime, the battle goes on. All three states that produce eggs agree on one thing: seven million laying hens in New England (not counting white-egg Connecticut) would produce just the right number of eggs for the region’s seven million people. 8 million residents (excluding Connecticut), if consumers would remain loyal to brown eggs. It was evident that what was needed was a strong advertising campaign charged with the responsibility of waging more aggressive war against white eggs. What emerged was the New England Brown Egg Council, and the money to run it comes from the egg producers. Most of the ads are aimed at the Boston, Providence, Portland, Springfield, and Worcester markets. In selecting an advertising theme, the Council was faced with the fact that there is no known nutritional difference between white and brown eggs, nor is there any detectable difference in taste. Brown eggs do have thicker shells, which slows air penetration and helps maintain freshness, but white eggs are “oiled” at the processing plant to maintain this same freshness. Brown eggs tend to be larger, but this doesn’t affect shoppers. However, the fact that brown eggs’ shells are less likely to break when they are boiled is not a very good reason to buy them. The slogan finally selected simply reinforces what New Englanders have always believed:
Brown eggs vs. white eggs: What’s the difference?
FAQ
Are brown eggs better than white eggs?
No, there is no nutritional difference between brown and white eggs.
What causes eggs to be brown?
A color called protoporphyrin is added to the shell as it forms in the hen’s oviduct, which is why brown eggshells happen. This pigment is a byproduct of hemoglobin breakdown and is similar to the pigment that gives blood its red color, but without the iron, according to the Australian Broadcasting Corporation.
Why are brown eggs more expensive?
Brown eggs are often more expensive than white eggs because the hens that lay them tend to be larger and require more feed, increasing the cost of production for farmers. Additionally, brown-egg laying breeds may have other characteristics, like needing more space or being less efficient layers, that contribute to higher overall costs.
What are the benefits of eating brown eggs?
Brown eggs, despite common misconceptions, do not inherently offer more nutritional value than white eggs. The breed of hen determines the color of the eggshell, but it doesn’t change the egg’s nutritional value or taste.